Skip to main content

Building the Enterprise

Recently came across buildtheenterprise.org, a site containing a plan to build a starship like the USS Enterprise from Star Trek. Despite some huge technical issues, lemme just come out first and say THANK YOU. Whoever you are, BTE-Dan, thank you for dreaming big. The world needs people to dream bigger. There's been an awful lack of big thinking ever since we put a man on the moon (over 40 years ago!). Neal Stephenson, one of my favorite authors, describes the problem in this talk:


Just a warning, if you haven't already watched the above - it's kinda depressing. He mentions how "I saw the best minds of my generation writing spam filters." Okay, I might have worked on Gmail.... Point taken, Neal.

Anyway, the Enterprise site lays out a crazy plan to build the friggin' Enterprise.

Image credit - Chris Martin of Evil Starship Factory

It's got some issues, though. One of the big things that I think is completely glossed over is how to actually assemble the thing in space. We've assembled reasonably large structures in space before, but the ISS is only 72.8m x 108.5m x 20m (according to Wikipedia), and that took an awful long time to put together. The Enterprise is almost 1000m long, so it's an order of magnitude bigger. I guess not completely out of reason, but I think the cost estimates are far too conservative ($1 trillion over 20 years).

Another problem seems to be the "gravity wheel", the large spinning wheel to simulate 1g of gravity for comfortable and healthy living aboard. Some various problems I've seen mentioned are:

The gravity wheel is in the wrong plane for control of the ship. Meaning you wouldn't be able to see where you're going, cause you'll be spinning around, so your "forward" is not the ship's "forward", except for a brief moment during each revolution (which would certainly be dizzying).

Well, this criticism only holds if you expect the real Enterprise to be like the fictional Enterprise, with a big window at the front of the bridge. But it doesn't take a lot of thought to realize that any orientation for the spinning wheel would render this impossible. However, who said anything about a window? Clearly this can be solved with a giant, extremely high-resolution digital display showing a live video feed of the direction you're headed, and having the controls also based on the direction you're heading rather than the direction you're actually facing (since again, you're constantly spinning around).

That being said, I do think the gravity wheel is in the wrong plane, but not for this reason. Due to Newton's Third Law, shouldn't the rotation of such a massive wheel spin the ship in the opposite direction (someone please correct me if this assumption is wrong)? If so, you'd want the gravity wheel spinning perpendicular to the direction of motion. However, in the Enterprise-type design, that would leave an awfully strange and unbalanced (even more so) ship. Otherwise, in the current design, one of the engines would need to constantly fire to offset the spinning of the ship, which is a waste of power.

It seems much better to have a simpler design for the ship, for instance something more like the Von Braun Space Station, or a derivative design like this:

Image taken from http://drexfiles.files.wordpress.com/2009/11/ringship07.jpg.

Now that would be a sick design. I could also imagine having the main engine in the center, and auxiliary engines located on the outside of the ring with the ability to move around the ring as needed. This way, it's very easy for the ship to accelerate without tumbling, and in case one or even two engines fail, the ship can still function properly. If the main and one auxiliary fail, the remaining engine can move around the ring at a constant rate, keeping the ship more or less balanced, or since the engines are already moving around the ship, can move into a center location. Plenty of interesting possibilities.

The gravity wheel will be affected by the constant acceleration of the ship. That is, since acceleration vectors are added, the ship's forward acceleration will be added with the rotational acceleration, meaning that "gravity" is different all around the wheel.


Luckily, for the first two generations of the ship, it doesn't really matter, since the targeted constant accelerations are 0.002g and 0.02g, which would be barely noticeable, unless you have an obsession with constantly weighing yourself.

By the time we reach a 1g constant acceleration in the third generation of the ship, well, it should be clear that there's no need for a spinning wheel at all =). At a constant acceleration of 1g, the "back wall" of the ship will already have a nice 1g force acting on it, so that entire surface will be perfectly hospitable to the starship inhabitants. Perhaps the ship's design will work like a giant transformer, putting most of the accessible spaces on this "back plane" of the ship, for a comfortable 1g journey to the next star system.

Anyway, it's fun to think about these things, but in the meantime, I'm beyond psyched for the SpaceX launch to the ISS on Saturday. So awesome what those guys have accomplished in such a short time. Can't wait till I can help the race for the future.
   


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Why Korean Is Hard For Native English Speakers

A couple of days ago, as an experiment, I wrote my first blog post ever in a non-English language. It was an attempt to explain some of the reasons that Korean is hard to learn for native English speakers, so I figured I might as well try to write it in Korean. Those of you who actually read Korean can see how awkward the attempt was =).

In any case, the post came from an email conversation I had with The Korean from Ask a Korean, a fantastically well-written blog about all things Korea from the perspective of a Korean who moved to the United States during high school. Since I tend to geek out on language things, I figured I might as well post part of that conversation. An edited version follows.

---------

Out of the languages that I've attempted to learn so far, Korean has been the hardest. I've done a lot of meta thinking about learning Korean, and I think there are a number of reasons it's difficult for non-Koreans (and especially Westerners) to learn:

1) Obviously, the…

Don't Take Korean Language Advice From Kyopos

I'm not sure why it took me so long to figure this out, but the last people you should take Korean language advice from are kyopos (foreign-born or raised Koreans). That being said, if you do follow their advice, you will get many laughs from Koreans. Some of my personal favorites, all of which actually happened to me:

- When I first got to Korea, I was at some open-air event, and during a break I started talking to one of the hosts. He said he was only a part-time host, so I asked him what his full-time job was, and he said "백수" (which is slang for "unemployed guy"). I asked him what that was, and he replied, "Comedian". So then the next few people I met, I proudly told I was a baeksu. (Edit: Actually, this guy was Korean Korean, not kyopo.)

- Next, a kyopo who lived in the apartment I moved into back in 2010 asked me what I was doing in Korea, and I told him I was starting a company, and asked how to say that in Korean in case people ask. He told me…

Is It Worth It To Learn Korean?

Learning Korean as a non-Asian foreigner is an exercise in masochism. Note that I specify "non-Asian". Why does that make a difference? Simply because Koreans possess a deeply-ingrained belief that non-Asians are incapable of speaking Korean. The self-fulfilling prophecy of it is that since Koreans expect you to be incapable of speaking Korean, due to this mental block, they are likely to not understand you regardless of your proficiency level. Additionally, they won't respond to you with normal Korean like they would respond to an Asian person, because they assume you couldn't possibly understand. You will rarely ever have an opportunity to hear natural Korean, because Koreans simply won't speak it with you unless 1) they are open-minded and awesome (meaning they have probably lived abroad - thank you to all of you), or 2) they have known you long enough that they've gotten past the odd sight of a foreigner speaking Korean.

In short, nearly every time you op…