Skip to main content

Siri-an Revolution

I used Siri for the first time a week or so ago, and I was exquisitely underwhelmed. It's basically a somewhat decent speech recognition system attached to a crappy version of Eliza, which was a simple question-and-answer artificial intelligence program written over 30 years ago. All of which begs the question - why do people love it so much?

Simply, Apple succeeded by humanizing Siri and then marketing the hell out of it (her?), even so far as to inspire various parodies such as the husband and wife argument. I've watched people use Siri with fascination, trying to tease out "sassy" responses, and searching for Easter eggs beyond what was reported in the press. In fact, I've seen this use case much more than actually useful things. But it's interesting anyway to compare with Google Voice Search, which has been around way longer and shares a similar feature set.

Google Voice Search is the best speech recognition system I've personally used. It's been getting increasingly better over time, and even learns how different individuals pronounce things differently. Android also added "Voice actions" a while back that essentially do what Siri does. So what's the problem? Why doesn't it get the attention that Siri does?

The problem is that most people don't even know these features exist. And the people that do know aren't compelled to use them. In both Apple's and Siri's cases, the feature sets are similar (Siri arguably has a larger vocabulary and better understanding of "natural language", but not by much). But in the case of Siri, people have an emotional connection, and perhaps it's this connection that pushes them to use what is clearly not yet a polished piece of technology.

What's curious is that Google has also shown the ability to connect emotionally with users, some examples being the absolutely brilliant "Search On" campaign that included the "Parisian Love" commercial shown during the Super Bowl, and most definitely the tear-jerker Chrome commercial "Dear Sophie". But in these cases, the marketing was much more general than "small feature of mobile operating system in order to convince people to buy my phone". This was by design, of course, but a notable difference nonetheless.

From a usability point of view, Apple unsurprisingly wins. How do you use Siri? Raise your phone and start talking after the beep. Yep, pretty darn simple. How do you use Voice Search/Actions (great name, btw....) on Android*? Well, there's a little microphone in the IME (that's "input method editor", for the inquisitive), in case you want to speak instead of typing. And there's a big microphone on the home screen next to the search box. And you can also press that big microphone button and tell it do something like, "Send a text message to Bob". And there's also this thing called "Voice Dialer" which does essentially a small part of what voice actions can do. Etc. Which experience would you feel more comfortable explaining to your parents? Yeah.

I always love observing how marketing and usability affect product outcomes, and since the battle between Android and iOS is only heating up, I can't wait to see what comes our way in the new year.

*I haven't seen ICS yet, so these comments are for older versions.


Popular posts from this blog

Why Korean Is Hard For Native English Speakers

A couple of days ago, as an experiment, I wrote my first blog post ever in a non-English language . It was an attempt to explain some of the reasons that Korean is hard to learn for native English speakers, so I figured I might as well try to write it in Korean. Those of you who actually read Korean can see how awkward the attempt was =). In any case, the post came from an email conversation I had with The Korean from  Ask a Korean , a fantastically well-written blog about all things Korea from the perspective of a Korean who moved to the United States during high school. Since I tend to geek out on language things, I figured I might as well post part of that conversation. An edited version follows. --------- Out of the languages that I've attempted to learn so far, Korean has been the hardest. I've done a lot of meta thinking about learning Korean, and I think there are a number of reasons it's difficult for non-Koreans (and especially Westerners) to learn: 1) Obvi

Stuttering in Korea

I had given up on English. It's my native language, but I figured after 30 some-odd years of disfluent speech, it was time to try something else. So I signed up for language classes in Korean, rationalizing that if I was going to try to teach myself how to speak, I might as well learn a new language along the way. This might seem completely insane, but when the prevailing theme of your conscious thoughts for multiple decades is some variant of "Why can't I say what I want to say?", you come up with lots of crazy ideas. For background, I've been a person who stutters for my entire life. I wrote about it on this blog a few years ago, so I think it's time for a followup. I've learned a lot since then, about myself and about stuttering, but in this post I simply want to give some insight into what it's actually like to stutter, and how my speech has changed over time. After the last stuttering post, the predominant reaction I got from friends was ei

Is It Worth It To Learn Korean?

Learning Korean as a non-Asian foreigner is an exercise in masochism. Note that I specify "non-Asian". Why does that make a difference? Simply because Koreans possess a deeply-ingrained belief that non-Asians are incapable of speaking Korean. The self-fulfilling prophecy of it is that since Koreans expect you to be incapable of speaking Korean, due to this mental block, they are likely to not understand you regardless of your proficiency level. Additionally, they won't respond to you with normal Korean like they would respond to an Asian person, because they assume you couldn't possibly understand. You will rarely ever have an opportunity to hear natural Korean, because Koreans simply won't speak it with you unless 1) they are open-minded and awesome (meaning they have probably lived abroad - thank you to all of you), or 2) they have known you long enough that they've gotten past the odd sight of a foreigner speaking Korean. In short, nearly every time you o